Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Layne A. Jackson's avatar

Vignette that didn't make the final cut into this post:

I (briefly) dated a leftist girl in college and one time she was talking about the American revolution and referred to Washington's army as "the Allies". It occurred to me that this is some sort of archetype that Star Wars Syndrome-ers have engrained into their little brains: there is always some "Alliance" working against a singular bad guy.

Most of us think WWII when we hear "the Allies" and I realize that she thought every "alliance" is just "The Allies". Like, the mere act of allying with someone other than yourself makes you a good guy in a vaguely diverse sort of way. I wonder if she realized that the Germans were **allied** to the Japanese or that several **alliances** tried to stop Napoleon, etc.

Also, who were we allied to? The French? Nobody won the revolution except for the Revolutionaries.

Expand full comment
Wolliver's avatar

That Reddit post you linked made me recoil with contempt. Every single /r/NonCredibleDefense user deserves to be strapped to an aerial drone and sent careening towards the Russian battle lines. Reddit midwit historical determinism is a plague on historical discourse.

They do this crap for every single historical conflict or phenomenon. Such and such is always “inevitable.” The Napoleonic Wars, the American Civil War, the rise and fall of the British Empire, the Industrial Revolution, the Christianization of Rome, the list goes on. If you asked them about their spiritual cosmology, they probably are going to say something about the “uncaring cruelty of the universe.”

Expand full comment
22 more comments...

No posts